Can You Have Medicare and Private Insurance?

Yes—you can have both. In fact, many people do.

If you’re approaching 65 or already enrolled in Medicare, you might be wondering whether you can keep your private insurance—especially if it’s through an employer, a spouse, or a retirement benefit.

The good news? Yes, you can have both Medicare and private insurance. In many cases, this “dual coverage” can reduce your out-of-pocket costs, expand your benefits, and give you more flexibility in your healthcare choices.

But as with most things in insurance, the details matter. How the plans work together, who pays first, and which combinations are allowed can all impact your coverage—and your wallet.

In this article, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know about having both Medicare and private insurance. You’ll learn:

• How dual coverage works

• The most common plan combinations

• What’s allowed (and what’s not)

• When it makes sense to keep both plans—or drop one

What Does It Mean to Have Medicare and Private Insurance?

When someone has both Medicare and private insurance, it means they are covered by two different health plans: one provided by the federal government and the other by a private insurer. These two plans work together to cover your medical expenses, but they don’t operate in isolation—there’s a process called coordination of benefits that determines which plan pays first and what the secondary plan will cover after that.

This kind of dual coverage is fairly common. People over 65 who are still working often remain on their employer’s health insurance and enroll in Medicare at the same time. Others may retire and purchase a Medicare Supplement Insurance plan (also known as Medigap), or choose a Medicare Advantage Plan, which is technically a private alternative to Original Medicare. Still others may be covered under their spouse’s insurance, military plans like TRICARE, or temporary continuation plans such as COBRA.

In every case, it’s important to understand the relationship between the two plans—not just that you have both, but how they interact. Does one pick up where the other leaves off? Are there services that are covered by one but not the other? Will you need to pay premiums for both? These are all important questions to answer, and they’ll depend on the specific combination of plans you have.

What Types of Private Insurance Work With Medicare?

There are several ways you can have Medicare and private insurance together. Let’s look at the most common pairings—and how they work.

Employer-Sponsored Insurance

If you’re still working after 65 or covered through your spouse’s employer, you can keep that private insurance while enrolling in Medicare. In this case, your employer’s plan usually pays first, and Medicare pays second.

This arrangement is common because Medicare Part A is free for most people and provides hospital coverage. Many people enroll in Part A at 65 but delay Part B (which has a premium) if they have strong employer coverage. Be sure to confirm whether your employer coverage qualifies as creditable coverage to avoid late penalties when you enroll in Medicare Part B later.

Spouse’s Coverage

If you’re on your spouse’s health plan through their employer, the situation is similar. That employer-sponsored plan typically remains the primary payer, while Medicare acts as secondary. Once your spouse retires or the employer plan ends, you’ll need to reevaluate your coverage.

COBRA

COBRA lets you keep your employer plan temporarily after you leave a job. But if you’re eligible for Medicare, you should enroll in Medicare first—otherwise, you could lose COBRA entirely. In a dual setup, Medicare pays first, and COBRA pays second. Be aware: COBRA is not considered creditable coverage for Medicare Part B, so delaying enrollment could lead to penalties.

TRICARE

TRICARE works with Medicare for military retirees and their families. Once you’re eligible for Medicare, you must enroll in both Part A and Part B to keep TRICARE benefits. After you do, Medicare pays first, and TRICARE covers what’s left—often with very little out-of-pocket cost.

Medigap (Medicare Supplement Insurance)

Medigap plans are purchased through private insurers to cover gaps in Original Medicare like copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles. Medicare pays first, and your Medigap plan fills in the rest. You must be enrolled in both Part A and Part B to buy a Medigap policy, and you can’t use Medigap with Medicare Advantage.

Medicare Advantage (Part C)

Medicare Advantage Plans are private plans that replace Original Medicare. They offer the same coverage as Parts A and B, but often include extras like dental, vision, hearing, and prescription drugs. In this case, your Medicare Advantage plan becomes your primary and only payer—you don’t use your Original Medicare card for services.

You cannot combine Medicare Advantage with Medigap. Choosing one excludes the other. That’s why it’s important to compare carefully.

Primary vs. Secondary Payer: Who Pays First?

When you have more than one health insurance plan, the two providers need to coordinate who pays which bills—and in what order. This process is called coordination of benefits, and understanding it is key to avoiding unexpected charges or coverage denials.

The plan that pays first is known as the primary payer, and the one that pays second is the secondary payer. The primary payer handles the bill up to its coverage limits, and the secondary payer may cover some or all of the remaining costs. If both plans deny coverage, or if there’s a gap between the two, you may be responsible for the difference.

Here are a few scenarios that illustrate how this works:

• If you’re still employed and have insurance through your job, and your employer has 20 or more employees, your employer plan typically pays first and Medicare pays second.

• If you’re retired and enrolled in Medicare and Medigap, Medicare pays first, and your Medigap policy picks up the rest.

• If you’re on COBRA after retirement or job loss, Medicare pays first, and COBRA pays second—assuming you’re properly enrolled in both.

• If you’re on TRICARE as a military retiree, Medicare also pays first, followed by TRICARE.

Why does this matter? Because if the wrong plan is billed first, your claim may be delayed or denied, potentially leaving you with a bill you weren’t expecting. Getting the order right ensures a smoother billing process and more predictable costs.

Pros and Cons of Having Both Medicare and Private Insurance

If you're eligible for Medicare, the idea of keeping private insurance as well might seem like a smart way to cover all your bases—and in many cases, it is. But having two types of coverage can also introduce unexpected complexity and cost. To determine whether dual coverage is the right fit for your needs, it’s important to look at both the advantages and potential downsides.

Benefits of Having Both

1. Broader Coverage for Medical Needs 

When you have both Medicare and private insurance, your overall healthcare coverage tends to be more comprehensive. That’s because the two plans often complement each other—what one doesn’t cover, the other might. For example, Medicare may cover your inpatient hospital stay, while your private plan might pick up part of the coinsurance or provide access to services Medicare excludes, like additional physical therapy sessions or mental health services.

This layered approach is especially helpful for people with chronic conditions, frequent doctor visits, or more complex medical needs. Having both plans gives you access to more resources and greater financial protection.

2. Lower Out-of-Pocket Expenses (in Many Cases) 

Perhaps the biggest draw of dual coverage is the potential to reduce your personal spending on healthcare. If one plan doesn’t cover the full cost of a treatment, the secondary plan might pay the difference. This can help reduce:

• Copayments

• Coinsurance

• Deductibles

• Unexpected bills

This is especially true if you have a Medigap plan, which is specifically designed to cover the “gaps” in Original Medicare. And for those on employer-sponsored coverage, combining plans may mean you hit your deductibles faster, leading to lower costs over the course of the year.

3. Access to a Wider Network of Doctors and Specialists 

Private insurance plans—particularly those obtained through an employer or retirement benefit—may offer broader provider networks compared to Medicare Advantage plans, which can be more limited by region or organization. Having both types of coverage increases the odds that your preferred doctors and specialists are within network.

For individuals who have built long-standing relationships with providers, or who need to see specialists regularly, this flexibility can be invaluable.

4. Additional Benefits Like Dental, Vision, and Prescription Drugs 

Original Medicare doesn’t cover most dental, vision, or hearing services—and it doesn’t automatically include prescription drug coverage. If your private insurance offers these benefits, keeping both plans could help ensure you have more complete care.

While Medicare Advantage plans may include some of these services, they can vary in scope and quality. A strong private plan can serve as a safety net for essential care Medicare typically excludes.

Drawbacks of Having Both

While the benefits can be compelling, dual coverage also comes with important caveats. If not managed carefully, it can lead to confusion, duplication, or unnecessary costs.

1. Higher Monthly Premiums 

Every plan comes with a cost. If you’re enrolled in Medicare and keeping your private insurance, you’ll likely be paying two sets of premiums. That includes:

• Your Medicare Part B premium (which most people must pay)

• Your Medicare Part D premium (if you opt for drug coverage and it’s not bundled)

• Your private insurance premium—whether through an employer, COBRA, retiree plan, or Medigap

This can quickly add up. For some individuals, the cost of maintaining both plans may outweigh the financial benefits unless you’re actively using a high level of medical services. It’s important to run the numbers—Unified Health can help you compare total monthly costs versus potential savings to decide what’s worth keeping.

2. More Complexity and Administrative Work 

Managing one health plan can be a headache. Managing two means twice the insurance cards, twice the provider networks, and often, a lot more confusion when it comes to who pays for what.

You may need to:

• Coordinate with multiple billing departments

• Follow up on claims that get rejected by one plan

• Track and submit receipts for reimbursement

• Understand two different sets of prior authorization rules

Even the order of billing (primary vs. secondary) can create challenges if your providers don’t file claims correctly. If you’re not familiar with how coordination of benefits works, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed.

3. Risk of Paying for Duplicate Coverage 

Some people pay for benefits they don’t realize they already have. For instance, if your Medicare Advantage plan includes prescription drug coverage, but you also pay for a private plan that covers the same medications, you’re effectively paying twice for the same service.

This can happen with:

• Prescription drugs

• Vision and dental coverage

• Wellness or gym memberships

• Telehealth services

• 
  

Unless the private plan offers significantly better versions of those benefits, the extra cost might not be worth it. That’s why it’s essential to conduct a full benefit comparison—not just to see what’s included, but to see how well those benefits are actually used.

4. Some Coverage Combinations Aren’t Allowed 

It’s also important to understand that not every type of private insurance can be combined with Medicare. One of the most common mistakes people make is trying to pair Medigap with a Medicare Advantage plan—which isn’t allowed. These plans are intended for two different types of Medicare users, and enrolling in both at the same time will cause conflicts.

Similarly, relying on COBRA after becoming eligible for Medicare can backfire if you delay enrollment in Medicare Part B, because COBRA is not considered creditable coverage in most cases. That mistake could result in a late penalty or even loss of COBRA benefits altogether.

Should You Keep Both?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Dual coverage may be the best decision for one person and an unnecessary cost for another. The key is understanding how your plans complement each other, what your actual health needs are, and how much you’re truly getting from each type of coverage.

Ask yourself:

• Are you actively using both plans, or is one just serving as backup?

• Are you paying more in premiums than you’re saving in cost-sharing?

• Would switching to a Medicare Advantage plan give you the same coverage in a simpler package?

• Are there duplicate benefits that could be consolidated?

If you’re not sure, Unified Health’s team of Medicare experts can walk through your current plan details and help you weigh the pros and cons specific to your situation—not just what works on paper.

Eligibility: Can Anyone Have Both?

Yes—anyone eligible for Medicare can also have private insurance, but your options may vary based on your age, employment status, and plan availability.

If you’re 65+ and working, you can usually keep your employer coverage. If you’re retired, you may be able to purchase Medigap or enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan. If you’re under 65 but receive Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI), you may also qualify for Medicare early.

That said, some forms of private insurance require you to enroll in Medicare on time to avoid losing your benefits. COBRA, for instance, often terminates once you become eligible for Medicare—even if you don’t sign up.

Because the rules can get complicated, we recommend working with a licensed advisor who can look at your personal situation and help you decide the best path forward.

Medicare vs. Private Insurance: Key Differences

Here’s a side-by-side comparison to help you understand how Medicare and private insurance differ:

Feature	Medicare	Private Insurance
Eligibility	Age 65+, or younger with certain conditions	Anyone at any age
Costs	Premiums, deductibles, coinsurance	Varies by plan (can include copays, etc.)
Flexibility	Limited networks with Original Medicare	Often broader provider networks
Drug Coverage	Optional with Part D	Often included
Dental & Vision	Not included (unless Medicare Advantage)	Often included
Can Combine?	Yes, with Medigap or employer plans	Depends on the plan type

Many people choose to keep both because they want access to broader care or extra benefits. Others prefer to simplify and stick with Medicare alone or pair it with a more targeted plan like Medigap or Medicare Advantage.

When Does It Make Sense to Drop One?

There may come a time when maintaining both Medicare and private insurance no longer makes sense. This could be due to cost, redundancy, or changes in your employment or health needs.

You might consider dropping your private plan if your employer premiums are high and Medicare covers everything you need. Conversely, you may choose to drop your Medicare Advantage plan if you’re enrolling in a new job-based plan that offers better benefits.

Another common reason to drop a plan is duplication. If both your Medicare plan and your private plan offer prescription drug coverage, you may be paying twice for the same service. Regularly reviewing your coverage can help you avoid unnecessary expenses and ensure you're only paying for what you need.

Before making a decision, always compare plan benefits, costs, and network access—and if you’re unsure, seek guidance from a professional.

Unified Health Can Help You Make the Right Choice

At Unified Health, we know how overwhelming Medicare can feel. That’s why we’re here to guide you—step by step.

Whether you’re figuring out how Medicare works with your employer insurance, considering Medigap or Medicare Advantage, or just trying to avoid penalties, our licensed advisors will make sure you understand your options and feel confident in your decision.

We offer:

• Personalized support based on your coverage needs

• Help avoiding late enrollment penalties

• Clarification on how plans work together

• Bilingual support and culturally competent care

• Ongoing support throughout your Medicare journey

We're more than just a Medicare resource—we're your partner in making healthcare decisions that truly work for you.

Get Personalized Help With Your Medicare Plan Today

Still unsure whether keeping both Medicare and private insurance is the right move for you?

Learn More

MULTIPLAN_UH_25124_C